Group Scrutiny Panel

The panel looks closely at how Wheatley Homes South and other parts of Wheatley Group performs.

Male housing officer using an iPad sitting with a female customer

Our Group Scrutiny Panel is another way customers can get involved. ‘Scrutiny’ is all about reviewing performance through a partnership approach, and working with staff to identify improvements to services.

Our award-winning Scrutiny Panel includes around 20 Customer Voices from across the four social landlords that make up Wheatley Group.

The Panel comes together at least four times a year to scrutinise performance using a hybrid meeting approach, giving members flexibility to take part in the way that works best for them. Members are supported to join remotely from the comfort of their own home should they wish or attend in person at a Wheatley office in Glasgow, Edinburgh or Dumfries.

This helps make participation accessible while still giving Panel members opportunities to meet and engage directly with staff from across Wheatley.

As well as reviewing quarterly performance, Panel members shape their agendas through selecting ‘spotlight’ topics – agendas are planned annually and reaffirmed ahead of each meeting.

The Panel also takes part in learning and development sessions which support members in their scrutiny role and build their knowledge and confidence, with topics directed by Panel members.

As well as reviewing quarterly performance, Panel members shape their agendas by selecting ‘spotlight’ topics. Agendas are planned annually and reaffirmed ahead of each meeting.

This year the Panel chose anti-social behaviour (ASB) as its area for thematic review.

So far, members have examined customer experiences, performance, processes, communications and the support available to customers affected by ASB. The Panel has considered how customers are kept informed, the support provided during longer or more complex cases and how Wheatley can continue to provide a consistent service to customers.

They are currently preparing a report and recommendations to deliver to Wheatley. An action plan in response will then be co-created with staff, tracked and reported back to the Panel.

Scrutinising our performance - November 2026

Key highlights from the November 2026 meeting include:

With senior management, the Panel scrutinised our quarter two Group performance against Scottish Social Housing Charter indicators, focusing on the performance priorities Panel members have chosen:

  • Anti-social behaviour (ASB) cases reported and resolved;​
  • Lettable homes that become vacant;​
  • Tenancy sustainment overall, plus for homeless source of lets​;
  • Time taken to resolve damp and mould cases and % re-opened; ​and
  • Complaint timescales.​

The Panel welcomed the Director of Neighbourhoods and Head of Neighbourhoods to discuss progress following its 2024 environmental review and how the recommendations continue to inform improvements across our communities.

The Panel also helped shape our Lettings Policy review by engaging with our Lettings and Homelessness Lead and sharing views and customer insight on the initial proposals.

The Panel continues to receive external support and development opportunities through the Tenant Participation Advisory Service (TPAS).

The Panel’s work has also received external recognition. In 2025, the Panel won the TPAS Good Practice Award for Involving Tenants in Shaping Services for its environmental services thematic review. In November 2026, its tenancy sustainment review was shortlisted for the Excellence in Tenant Scrutiny Award at the Chartered Institute of Housing Scotland Awards.

Panel members also attended the TPAS Scrutiny Summit, providing an opportunity to learn from good practice and share experiences with other scrutiny groups.

Interested in getting involved?

We’re always interested in hearing from customers who would like to get involved in the Scrutiny Panel. If you’d like to join, please get in touch with Morgan English by email at morgan.english@wheatley-group.com or complete our register of interest form here.  When the Panel is at full capacity, we’ll add you to our waiting list and keep you informed about future opportunities.

Group Scrutiny Panel (2025) - Tenancy Sustainment Thematic Review
 

In 2025, the Wheatley Group Scrutiny Panel carried out a thematic review looking at how well Wheatley helps tenants to stay in their homes. The Panel – made up of over 20 customers from across Wheatley Homes Glasgow, South, East and Loretto – chose this topic because tenancy sustainment is a key measure of how effectively housing services support people to manage and maintain their tenancy.

Between April and September 2025, Panel members met regularly to speak with staff, visit services, review performance information and gather feedback from tenants and employees.

The review focused on support provided through Wheatley Foundation services, including Home Comforts. The Panel’s findings and recommendations are set out in the full report and a short summary document, both available to download below.

Scrutiny Panel - Environmental review 2024/2025
 

Customers have told us how important our environmental service is to communities.

That’s why our Group Scrutiny Panel, which comprises around 25 customers from Wheatley communities across Scotland, chose to take a close look at this key service to find areas for improvement.

Members of the Panel interested in being involved in the review formed a thematic group that scrutinised the vast offering of our environmental services and decided to focus on Neighbourhood Environmental Teams (NETs) and waste management. Below are the highlights of the thematic review which took place between April and October 2024.

During the review the thematic group met with key staff from different parts of Wheatley, including our Director and Environmental Services and NETs leaders. They also reviewed information including process maps, performance reports, customer insight and satisfaction results, example work programmes and Keep Scotland Beautiful (KSB) information.

The group had the opportunity to visit three sites, in Glasgow, Edinburgh and Dumfries, and chat with local NETs and a KSB assessor. This was followed up with a survey to Customer Voices and Lowther owners, which informed 4 focus groups to gain a better understanding of the customer view of our environmental services and their priorities.

Throughout the review the group was supported by Tenant Participation Advisory Service (TPAS) – an independent national tenant and landlord participation advisory service

The group has now completed its review and produced its own independent report. That report includes 12 recommendations to help Wheatley Group improve our environmental services.

The group has now met with our key staff to discuss each recommendation and co-create solutions. Some of the key messages from the review that customers would like to highlight include:

  • Clarity of information and communication are vital to ensure customers are kept informed and are aware, in advance, of upcoming NETs services and engagement; and
  • Wheatley Group must support understanding for customers to be clear on their responsibilities for example, around waste management.

Thematic group members were pleased with the information provided by Wheatley Group during the review and with the free access to staff at all levels. The thematic group was impressed at the commitment, passion and enthusiasm shown by staff, and in particular, commented that the local NETs staff they engaged with at the site visits, including concierge and arborists, had a real sense of pride in their work.

Wheatley Group would like to thank the Panel members for their time and commitment in undertaking this review. At Wheatley, we are always looking to work with customers to improve our services, and this review will help us do that. Members of the Scrutiny Panel, and other customers, will be involved in monitoring our progress in actioning solutions to the recommendations.

Interested in finding out more? You can read the full report here.

You can also hear what the customers had to say here in our short video.

Scrutiny Panel - Repairs communication review 2023/2024
 

Members of the thematic group identified repairs communication as an area for review and commenced its work in July 2023, with an initial planning meeting taking place and then a visit to the Customer First Centre in August 2023.

Following the review, the repairs thematic group worked with TPAS to develop a report with recommendations.  The group then met with staff to discuss their report and its findings, co-creating solutions to the recommendations.  Members of the group have attended Board meetings to discuss their experience with board members.  The group met with staff in June 2024 to discuss progress and review the improvements made/underway.

Find a summary of the report here or read the full report here.

You can also hear what customers had to say by watching the video below.